Brown Sugar Pop Tart Cookies Recipe

If you’re a fan of all things nostalgic and sweet, you’re in for a treat: these Brown Sugar Pop Tart Cookies take everything you love about the classic toaster pastry—tender brown sugar filling, cinnamon warmth, buttery dough, and a glossy glaze—and transform it into a thick, bakery-style cookie you’ll want to make again and again.

Ingredients You’ll Need

The best part about these cookies? The ingredient list is simple but absolutely essential—each one brings something special, from tender crumb to that classic brown sugar-cinnamon magic. Here’s why every component deserves its spot.

• Unsalted Butter: Room-temperature butter is the key to a rich, creamy base and flavorful filling; just be sure it’s cool, not melty, for thick cookies.
• Granulated Sugar: Adds sweetness and helps give the cookie just a touch of that familiar pop tart crunch.
• Light Brown Sugar: The star of both cookie and filling, for caramel notes and signature gooey centers.
• Eggs: Bring structure and richness, helping the cookies bake up chewy but not cakey.
• Vanilla Extract: Rounds out the flavors and enhances all those brown sugar-cinnamon notes.
• Cake Flour: Results in a soft, plush cookie crumb reminiscent of bakery treats—don’t swap for all-purpose if you want the true Pop Tart experience!
• Cornstarch: Lends delicate tenderness to the cookie and helps create thickness.
• Baking Soda & Baking Powder: The combination encourages the dough to puff up just right—chewy on the edges and soft in the center.
• Kosher Salt: Balances the sweetness and enhances every subtle flavor.
• Cinnamon: Essential for that warm, nostalgic “Pop Tart” flavor in the filling and the glaze.
• Powdered Sugar: Makes a silky-smooth icing that sets beautifully atop each cookie.
• Milk: Just enough to create a glossy glaze that spreads to the edges—but won’t run right off.

Variations

The magic of Brown Sugar Pop Tart Cookies is how easily they adapt for any taste or occasion—so don’t be afraid to get creative and make them your own. Tweak the filling, the glaze, or even the flour based on your mood or pantry!

• Chocolate Filling: Swap the cinnamon-brown sugar for a chocolate spread, or add mini chocolate chips to create a decadent twist on the classic.
• Maple Glaze: Add a teaspoon of pure maple syrup to the glaze for an extra layer of breakfast-inspired flavor.
• Whole Wheat Option: Replace half of the cake flour with whole wheat pastry flour for a heartier, nuttier cookie (keep it tender by not swapping all of it).
• Gluten-Free: Use a 1:1 gluten-free baking flour in place of cake flour—just note that texture may be a little less soft, but still delicious.

How to Make Brown Sugar Pop Tart Cookies

Step 1: Cream the Butter and Sugars

Start by beating the room-temperature butter with both granulated and brown sugar in your mixer until it looks airy and pale—about 2-3 minutes. This step is where you lay the foundation for chewy, thick Brown Sugar Pop Tart Cookies that melt in your mouth every time.

Step 2: Mix in Eggs and Vanilla

Add eggs and vanilla, then continue mixing until the batter is light and fluffy. Don’t rush this part—it helps to emulsify everything together for a dough that bakes up soft and flavorful.

Step 3: Combine and Chill the Dough

Whisk together cake flour, cornstarch, baking powder, baking soda, and salt in a separate bowl. Mix these dry ingredients into your wet mixture until a dough forms—be sure to scrape down the sides. Cover and chill for at least 1 hour; this step is key to cookies that hold their shape and keep their thick, plush texture.

Step 4: Prepare the Brown Sugar Filling

Stir together softened butter, brown sugar, cinnamon, and a touch of flour for stability. Roll heaping teaspoons (about 2 teaspoons each) into balls—this luscious, cinnamon-infused mixture is what sets Brown Sugar Pop Tart Cookies apart!

Step 5: Shape and Fill the Cookies

Use a 1/4 cup cookie scoop or measuring cup to portion the chilled dough. Break each dough ball in half, make a well in one piece, nestle a filling ball inside, and top with the other half, pinching to seal. Roll into a ball—don’t worry if it looks rustic! That’s the charm.

Step 6: Bake to Golden Perfection

Arrange the stuffed dough balls on parchment-lined baking sheets, leaving space to spread. Bake at 350°F for 11–13 minutes—just until the tops are set and edges are lightly golden. Let them cool 5 minutes on the tray before transferring to a wire rack.

Step 7: Glaze and Set

While the cookies cool, whisk up your cinnamon glaze. Drizzle or spoon it over each cookie, letting it gently drip to the edges. The glaze will set in about 15 minutes—worth the wait, I promise!

How to Serve Brown Sugar Pop Tart Cookies

Garnishes

Try sprinkling the freshly glazed cookies with a dusting of cinnamon, festive sprinkles, or a tiny pinch of flaky salt for an extra layer of flavor and visual wow-factor. You can even add a few toasted chopped pecans for a bit of crunch.

Side Dishes

Nothing pairs better with Brown Sugar Pop Tart Cookies than a tall glass of cold milk or a cozy cup of coffee or chai. For a dessert platter, serve them alongside fresh berries, vanilla ice cream, or even a fruit salad to balance their buttery sweetness.

Creative Ways to Present

Stack them on a vintage cake stand, arrange them in a pretty box with parchment for gifting, or make a “cookie board” with mini Pop Tart Cookies, fruit, and dipping chocolate for a party centerpiece—there’s no wrong way to serve joy!

Make Ahead and Storage

Storing Leftovers

Once glazed and cooled, store your Brown Sugar Pop Tart Cookies in an airtight container at room temperature for up to three days—they’ll stay soft and flavorful. For longer freshness, refrigerate them for up to a week (let them come to room temp before serving for the best texture).

Freezing

Freeze un-iced baked cookies or stuffed dough balls on a baking sheet until solid, then transfer them to a zip-top freezer bag. They’ll keep perfectly for up to three months; just thaw overnight in the fridge and add glaze before serving if you’re freezing baked cookies.

Reheating

To gently refresh cookies (especially if they’ve been refrigerated or frozen), let them sit at room temp, or briefly warm them in a low oven (about 275°F for a couple of minutes)—just until soft and aromatic again. If using the microwave, a quick 5-second burst does the trick, but avoid melting the glaze.

FAQs

Final Thoughts

There’s nothing quite like baking a batch of Brown Sugar Pop Tart Cookies—whether for a cozy night in, a party treat, or just a sweet little moment of nostalgia. Give them a try, and I guarantee they’ll become a new favorite in your kitchen for years to come!

Print